Thursday, November 19, 2026

The Fiction of Costs and Profits

Several times a year there's an "environmental disaster" news story. They always make me think of Love Canal which is an over the top egregious case. Anyway the disaster du jour is a garbage geyser in Los Angeles. Aeresolized garbage splooged all over the fancy pants neighborhoods adjacent to the landfill. The landfill is only about 10 miles from the neighborhood I visit for work a couple of times a year.

Environmental disaster stories are all some version of Love Canal. Nobody wants to really spend the money required to properly dispose of garbage or industrial waste, or deal with accidents properly.

How much does it truly cost to do anything like make a car, produce a gallon of gasoline, make an EV battery, etc...? There's really not an answer, because the costs of disposal and damage to the environment are ongoing. For example, it's common for oil companies to go bankrupt and leave uncapped wells in their wake. Even properly capped wells require maintenance or even just monitoring. In the gameified world, some group of owners and execs of those oil companies are shielded from responsibility for the damage they caused by an arbitrary set of rules that everyone just goes along with.

The game casts the executives and managers of companies as agents for the whole population. It protects them from liability and financial responsibility because they arguably act on behalf of "the public interest", even when they cause environmental damage. This is most obvious in the case of something like the Los Angeles garbage geyser, but it's even true for the oil industry, or the chemical industry.

Generally in the wake of these incidents politician scumbags and media scumbags argue about why "the game" doesn't really work. A fairly common trope is the executives of the game weren't managing things well enough, or maybe they were corrupt, or incompetent or whatever. The dumbest trope is political party "A" didn't manage the thing as well as political party "B" would have. Another trope is there is a "fix" for everything.


No comments:

Post a Comment